Ideal Roofing | Multi-Award Winning Metal Roofing Professionals
  • Why Ideal
    • Projects >
      • Commercial & Industrial
    • Suppliers
    • WHS & Environment
    • Community Involvement
    • Testimonials
  • Services
    • Construction >
      • New Construction
      • Roof Replacement
      • Asbestos Removal
      • Wall Cladding & Facades
    • Ideal Asset Maintenance
  • Rooftop Views
  • Contact
  • Ideal Careers
(02) 9525 2066

ROOFTOP VIEWS

rOOF rEPAIR VS. ROOF REPLACEMENT

8/2/2018

29 Comments

 
Picture
Roofs only have a limited lifespan. Even the best roof will only last a hundred years, and humans have been building houses for thousands so it is inevitable that roofs will need to be replaced eventually. It can be a considerably costly endeavour but choosing to do it at the right time, rather than paying for repair after repair, can save you money in the long run. In this article we will discuss some key points to consider when deciding on whether to replace or repair your roof. If you are in doubt, it is always better to have an inspection performed by a qualified roofing specialist.

When to Repair Your Roof

Every roof install should come with a warranty and an expected lifespan. If you are still within your warranty when you notice a problem with the roof, a repair should definitely be the first point of call. Most warranties will expire before the roof itself does, so if the roof is still in pretty good condition, get it repaired.
Spot damage, caused by mould or rot is not a cause to have your whole roof replaced. Similarly, chance encounters with falling objects like tree branches should not lead you to replace your roof unless the damage is so substantial a repair is basically a rebuild anyway.
Chances are good that the serviceman you employ to repair your roof will be able to provide a roofing inspection at the same time. Given that roofing troubles have a tendency to start small and get worse, even if you aren’t aware of a problem that needs repairing employing a quality roofer to perform an inspection is not a bad idea.

When to Replace Your Roof

A roof should be replaced when repairs are going to cost more or be required too frequently. If it feels like you are calling someone in to repair your roof every other week then it is time to get a new one.
Curled or cracked shingles are a good sign your roof needs to be replaced. As is a steady build-up of roofing materials in your gutters several years after their installation.

SAGGING ROOF

If your entire roof is sagging it is an extremely bad sign. This points to structural problems and this should be addressed immediately.

The Advantage of a Metal Roof Replacement

Replacing your roof with a metal roof can be a very wise decision because it can be mounted on top of your existing roof. It might sound strange, but it means that the existing thermal insulation properties of your heavier tiled roof can be preserved and less waste is generated.

Contact Ideal Roofing for a FREE consultation now.

Ideal Roofing are experts in the roofing industry with more than 40 years of experience across the commercial, industrial and residential sectors. We offer a full range of roofing services including consulting, installation, maintenance, service and repair. Crucially we are trained and accredited in removal of fibre concrete or asbestos laden roofing in a safe manner. Call us on (02) 9525 2066 or use our online form to book your appointment.
29 Comments
Sarah Smith link
26/6/2020 04:06:36 am

Thanks for explaining that curled and cracked shingles mean you need to replace your roof rather than repair it. My husband and I have noticed some shingles being shaken loose after storms. I'll check tomorrow morning to see if the remaining shingles are curling so I'll know if we need to replace them.

Reply
Kris Glunt link
24/9/2020 05:28:35 pm

This is a pretty underrated blog post. This is actually very helpful if you are someone who have no involvement in constructions and stuff. True that some roof comes with warranty, that's why it is still better to avail a quality roof, may costly but what we are seeing is the long run. Specially when you are in countries with only wet and dry seasons.

Reply
Pauline Gullette link
23/2/2022 03:15:15 am

Roof replacement involves removing all the old shingles and felt paper or moisture barrier and replacing them with brand new materials. Thank you for taking the time to write a great post!

Reply
Patricia Vandervort link
19/3/2022 04:21:58 am

The serviceman you employ to repair your roof will be able to provide a roofing inspection at the same time. Thank you, amazing post!

Reply
Larry Stephens link
23/3/2022 08:46:52 am

In this article we will discuss some key points to consider when deciding on whether to replace or repair your roof. Thank you for the beautiful post!

Reply
Inventory Management Development link
4/5/2022 06:57:36 am

Inventory management is the entire process of managing inventories from raw materials to finished products. Inventory Management Software helps in tracking the goods moving in and out of the company's locations.

Reply
Laurel Cline link
24/5/2022 11:55:32 pm

Great post thaank you

Reply
Consumer Goods CRM link
24/6/2022 04:41:22 am

CRM applications will ensure that customer inquiries are not lost, neglected or misplaced. Requests logged into the main system can be accessed online.

Reply
Roof Replacement San Antonio link
18/3/2023 08:15:33 pm

This article provides useful information for homeowners in deciding between roof repair and roof replacement. It suggests that if you are still within your warranty period, repairing the roof should be your first point of call. However, if repairs are becoming too frequent or too costly, then it is time to consider a roof replacement. The article also recommends a metal roof replacement as a wise decision, as it can preserve the existing thermal insulation properties of the roof and generate less waste.

Reply
Jobin Reddy link
21/3/2023 04:20:49 pm

Great blog post! As a homeowner, it can be a tough decision to make between roof repair and replacement. Your article provided some helpful insights into factors to consider, such as the age of the roof and the extent of damage. Thanks for sharing!



Reply
San Antonio Roof Inspection link
30/3/2023 10:18:15 pm

Deciding between repairing or replacing your roof can be a difficult decision, but it's important to consider the cost and frequency of repairs. Repairs are appropriate for minor issues, such as spot damage or falling objects, while a replacement may be necessary for consistent repairs or significant damage. If considering a replacement, a metal roof can be a wise choice due to its ability to be mounted on top of an existing roof, preserving thermal insulation properties and reducing waste. Ultimately, it's best to have a qualified roofing specialist perform an inspection to determine the best course of action.

Reply
concrete-calculator.org/ link
31/3/2023 10:35:02 pm

Great blog post! Your comparison of roof repair versus roof replacement was really informative and helpful. I appreciated the way you explained the pros and cons of each option in a clear and concise manner, making it easy to understand which choice would be best for my specific situation. Your emphasis on the importance of consulting with a professional to make an informed decision was also spot on. Overall, this post provided a valuable resource for anyone considering roof repair or replacement, and I would highly recommend it to others.




Reply
Sheena Mestica link
6/4/2023 10:56:42 am

In order to replace a roof, all of the old shingles, felt paper, or moisture barriers, must be removed and replaced with brand-new ones. I appreciate you taking the time to write this excellent post!

Reply
Sean Salgado link
17/5/2023 03:41:14 pm

I appreciate the inclusion of specific scenarios and examples to illustrate when roof repair is a viable solution and when roof replacement becomes a more practical choice. The post covers factors such as the extent of damage, the age of the roof, energy efficiency considerations, and long-term cost-effectiveness. This helps readers better understand the factors that influence the decision-making process. Thank you to Ideal Roofing for sharing this informative content. I look forward to exploring more of your blog posts in the future.

Reply
Shreya link
15/6/2023 07:31:36 pm

Thanks for all the information. Found this really insightful.

Reply
Tactical Roofing link
6/7/2023 09:31:30 pm

The blog post on Ideal Roofing comparing roof repair versus roof replacement is highly informative. It's crucial to understand the key differences and factors to consider when faced with a damaged roof. This article provides valuable insights into when to opt for repairs and when a replacement may be necessary. The explanations and examples provided help homeowners make informed decisions about their roofing needs. Thank you for sharing this helpful resource!

Reply
ROOFING REPAIR COTGRAVE, NOTTINGHAM link
14/1/2024 03:13:41 pm

Understanding the signs for roof repair or replacement is essential, and this article offers useful criteria. The mention of curled or cracked shingles and sagging roofs as indicators is insightful. Additionally, the suggestion of a metal roof replacement is a smart consideration for preserving insulation.

Reply
ROOFING REPAIR KEYWORTH, NOTTINGHAM link
18/1/2024 12:54:14 am

Considering a metal roof replacement is a smart move, and the article sheds light on the advantages, including preserving thermal insulation and minimizing waste. Helpful information for those navigating roof-related decisions.

Reply
John Ruzghani link
5/8/2024 04:24:19 pm

Nice Post!!! Thanks for sharing this post about Roof Repair………..Good Job…………..

Reply
Nakib Momen link
15/10/2024 06:14:25 am

Hey,

This post provides a clear and helpful guide on deciding between roof repair and replacement! I appreciate the emphasis on understanding the lifespan of your roof and knowing when a repair is sufficient versus when a full replacement is needed. The points about frequent repairs and structural issues like a sagging roof are crucial in making the right decision.

The suggestion to consider a metal roof replacement is also insightful—it’s a great way to save on insulation and reduce waste. And of course, always getting a professional inspection is spot on for peace of mind.

Best regards,
Nakib

Reply
Robert Jones link
16/10/2024 11:55:19 am

Great article! I'll definitely keep an eye out for signs that it's time to replace my roof, like curled or cracked shingles and excessive roofing materials in my gutters. It's also helpful to know that a sagging roof is a major red flag.

Reply
KVN Portland Roofing link
6/1/2025 09:50:07 pm


Great insights on roof repair versus replacement! At KVN Portland Roofing, we couldn't agree more on the importance of timely roof inspections and understanding when it's more cost-effective to repair rather than replace. Our team of experienced roofing specialists in Portland, OR, is always ready to provide a thorough inspection to help homeowners make informed decisions about their roofs.

As you mentioned, small issues like mold or rot don’t always warrant a full replacement—often, a quality roof repair can restore the integrity of the roof. However, when you notice recurring issues or structural damage like sagging, it's definitely time to consider a replacement. We also encourage our customers to explore long-term solutions, such as metal roofing, which offers durability and can often be installed over existing roofing for added efficiency.

KVN Portland Roofing has been providing expert roofing services to the Portland area for years, from roof repairs to complete replacements. We're committed to ensuring the longevity of your roof while delivering top-notch service. If you're unsure whether it's time for a repair or replacement, don’t hesitate to contact us for a free consultation!

Keep up the great work on providing valuable roofing advice!

Reply
john link
6/1/2025 10:27:23 pm

Very informative blog post I have read today! Thanks for sharing.

Reply
Alex Cela link
20/2/2025 08:44:03 pm

This article is so informative! It's helpful to know the specific signs to look out for when deciding between repairing and replacing a roof. The advice about calling in a specialist for an inspection is a great reminder, as sometimes roof issues can go unnoticed until they’re bigger problems. I especially found the point about a sagging roof to be concerning—it really shows how important it is to address structural issues immediately. Also, the idea of opting for a metal roof replacement is interesting; it seems like a smart way to minimize waste and take advantage of existing insulation. Thanks for the helpful tips!

Reply
Sky Roofer link
27/2/2025 03:06:59 am

This article helps clarify when to choose roof repair or replacement, depending on the damage and cost. How do you decide whether to repair or replace your roof?

Reply
Roof repair San Antonio link
30/3/2025 01:31:08 pm

Deciding between roof repair and roof replacement depends on the extent of the damage and the age of your roof. At Bondoc Roofing, we provide expert assessments to help you make the best choice for your home. Whether you need a minor repair or a full replacement, our team ensures quality workmanship and lasting results. Contact Bondoc Roofing today for a free inspection! #RoofRepair #RoofReplacement #BondocRoofing

Reply
Roof Replacement Poughkeepsie NY link
9/4/2025 12:01:36 am

Deciding between repair and replacement can be tricky. These pointers make it much clearer. Good work.

Reply
Rooftek link
17/4/2025 08:13:44 pm

Great insights in this post—timing truly is everything when it comes to deciding between roof repair and full replacement. At Rooftek, a trusted Millcreek Roofing Company, we’ve helped countless homeowners make that decision with confidence through expert inspections and honest assessments. As a leading Roofer in Millcreek, UT, we specialize in high-quality repairs and replacements that prioritize longevity and value. Whether you're dealing with cracked shingles, sagging structures, or simply aging materials, our team of seasoned professionals is here to deliver dependable roofing services that meet your needs. If you're searching for a reliable roofing contractor in Millcreek, Rooftek is here to help you protect what matters most.

Reply
Infinity Roofers INC link
11/7/2025 11:41:13 pm

Great article! It's so important for homeowners to understand the difference between roof repair and full replacement—especially when trying to manage costs and avoid long-term damage. We run a roofing business in Simi Valley, CA and often help clients make this same decision based on roof age, material, and weather damage. Appreciate the clear breakdown here!

Reply



Leave a Reply.

    Categories

    All
    Asbestos Removal
    Asset Management
    Colour
    Commercial
    Environmentally Friendly
    Green Roof
    Guttering
    Home Makeover
    Industrial
    Living Roofs
    Maintenance
    Material
    Metal Flashing
    Metal Roofing
    Multi Residential
    Multi-Residential
    Preventative Maintenance
    Refurbishment
    Residential
    Roof Cleaning
    Roof Damage
    Roof Education
    Roofing
    Roofing Trends
    Roof Inspection
    Roof Leak
    Roof Maintenance
    Roof Repair
    Roof Replacement
    Roof Tips
    Roof Vegetation
    Skylights
    Slate Roofing
    Solar Panels
    Storm Damage
    Strata

    RSS Feed

Ideal Roofing
Why Ideal
Projects
Services
Blog
Contact
Ideal Careers
​(02) 9525 2066​
​
[email protected]
Picture
Picture
Picture
Picture
Picture

​COPYRIGHT © 1992-2025 IDEAL ROOFING    |    PRIVACY POLICY    |    WEBSITE DISCLAIMER

  • Why Ideal
    • Projects >
      • Commercial & Industrial
    • Suppliers
    • WHS & Environment
    • Community Involvement
    • Testimonials
  • Services
    • Construction >
      • New Construction
      • Roof Replacement
      • Asbestos Removal
      • Wall Cladding & Facades
    • Ideal Asset Maintenance
  • Rooftop Views
  • Contact
  • Ideal Careers